Timer Conflict

[Huevos]

Vu Ultimo, 3 tuners configured for 28E.

Trying to record the Mentalist.

Timer 1
Channel: 5*
Thu 21:57...23:05 (68 mins)

Timer 2
Channel: 5*+1
Thu 22:57...0:05 (68 mins)

I don't understand how this could be a timer conflict anyway as they are both on the same transponder. I've checked using the Duo and it does not throw this error.

Screenshots from the Ultimo and Duo.